Bloody Rose Book Review – Ogre’s Book Club

Welcome back to the second installment of Ogre’s Book Club. This time I’m doing the Bloody Rose book review I promised when I published the review of Kings of the Wyld.

Here’s the note about spoilers: I will try to avoid spoilers as much as possible in these reviews. I don’t want to ruin suspense or surprises for the readers. However, a bit of a plot summary is necessary and I’ll be honest, there are some spoilers in this review. I will start those paragraphs with a spoiler warning.

Bloody Rose is OK

I’ll get right to it. Bloody Rose is okay. Kings of the Wyld was much better. As with the previous book, it’s about 500 pages and an easy read. I finished it in a couple of days.

Richard Anderson’s Cover Art is Fantastic

Richard Anderson illustrated the covers for both Kings of the Wyld and Bloody Rose. As I mentioned in my previous article, his cover of Bloody Rose is what caught my eye at my local book store and the reason I wound up buying both books. Since this is an art focused blog, I would be remiss not to point you to his excellent portfolio.

Discovering Eames

If you haven’t read my review of Kings of the Wyld, you should read that post now. Kings of the Wyld is amazing and fun and precedes Bloody Rose.

What I liked about Bloody Rose

Here’s what I liked. Bloody Rose has the same fun, rollicking, non-standard fantasy thing going for it that Kings of the Wyld had. Mercenary and adventuring bands are patterned after rock stars. They “tour” when they go out and adventure. They “perform” in arenas, and they have groupies that follow them from venue to venue. The old “bands” are better than the new “bands” and old people and young people argue about it. There are lots of parties and other shenanigans that you might find backstage or at a music festival. It’s a very refreshing take on the fantasy novel.

What I didn’t like about Bloody Rose

I finished Bloody Rose a week ago and I’ve been sitting on this review for a few days now. I had to let it marinate because I want to be fair about the parts of the book that I didn’t like, or at least that didn’t live up to it’s predecessor, Kings of the Wyld. So, take this with a grain of salt. It’s just one person’s opinion, but I’d be remiss if I didn’t publish the bad as well as the good in a series of book reviews.

It felt hurried.

I didn’t find that any of Bloody Rose was as well developed as Kings of the Wyld was. It felt rushed and I had the impression that there might have been pressure to put out a sequel after the success that Kings had.

A lot of things take place in the first 200 pages of Bloody Rose, but nothing happens. Overall, I think this book should have been two books. The story has enough material for two books. There’s even a place where I felt the book should end and the remainder saved for another book. If you read it, I’m sure you’ll know exactly where that spot is. It would have allowed a similar level of development and depth as Kings of the Wyld. For me, Bloody Rose just skims the wavetops from start to finish and all the character development and world building and tension is missing. I might not notice it as much had the previous book not been so much better.

Everyone has daddy issues.

All of the characters in Bloody Rose’s band, Fable, have daddy issues. Each and every one of them is built on a series of cliches and tropes and none (except maybe Rose herself) have them addressed well enough in the story telling to make you feel for the characters.

Definitely not Wonder Women

Cura, the “ink witch” is perhaps the worst example of a character that could have been great, but isn’t. The concept of the character is absolutely bad ass. A summoner that breathes life into her tattoos and through them fights battles alongside her mates. Wow.

However, after reading the book you find that Eames has balled this great concept into a crumpled mess and basically thrown it away in favor of this cliche: Goth girl dresses in all black and hurts herself (tattoos) and is very sexually promiscuous because mommy didn’t pay enough attention to her and daddy sexually abused her. Really? What a missed opportunity.

I’m sure any female reader that might have been attracted to the book because the cover makes it look like it’s about powerful female characters with starring roles will be sorely disappointed. All of the female characters are written poorly and are paper thin caricatures of women. His character development in Bloody Rose is shockingly different from the predominantly male characters in Kings of the Wyld.

Spoiler: At the end of the book Cura suddenly lets go of her pain and fears and all her tattoos vanish, but you never learn why and nothing in the story builds to it. What a completely wasted opportunity.

Bloody Rose Book Review – In Conclusion

Well, that’s probably enough. I’m sure its obvious that I’m disappointed in Bloody Rose. It doesn’t live up to Kings of the Wyld at all. Should Eames write another book in the series, I will probably buy it and see if he can recapture that which made Kings of the Wyld special.

Thanks for reading my Bloody Rose book review. I’m churning my way through RA Salvatore’s Companion’s Codex and I’m also going to post the art book review of Frazetta: Icon soon.